kinds of drugs and its side effects

Dogs shouldn’t suffer for Leona’s sins

Leona Helmsley is a public relations nightmare.

Notoriously high-handed, she was dubbed the “Queen of Mean” by employees at the hotel empire her husband, Harry, built. She famously remarked, “Only the little people pay taxes” — before she went to jail for tax evasion. In her will, she left bupkis to two of her grandchildren.

It’s easy to dismiss her as a rich bitch who overindulged another rich bitch, her Maltese, Trouble.

File photo, 2003: Leona and Trouble

File photo, 2003: Leona loves Trouble

Trouble isn’t the best spokesdog for canine causes either, through no fault of her own. She didn’t need (or ask for) the $12 million that Helmsley originally set aside for her care. The reduction of that bequest to a mere $2 million by the courts was not unreasonable. How much home-cooked food can a small dog eat? How much vet care would a well-walked pup require? And Trouble can’t distinguish fake diamonds from the real deal.

But Helmsley didn’t only love Trouble. She also loved other dogs that she didn’t know personally. How do we know? Because she left billions of dollars for their care.

Now the trustees of her estate are trying to divert the money to other charitable causes. This, naturally, brings up the larger issue of whether it’s okay to subvert someone’s final wishes.

Luckily, the dogs have some powerful spokespeople: The Humane Society of the United States, The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, and Maddie’s Fund are going to court on their behalf.

The Humane Society is not without its own controversy (can you say “spokesperson Michael Vick?”). And while the ASPCA is a fine organization, I’d like to focus here on Maddie’s Fund, the least known of the three.

Because Maddie is a dream of a spokes-Schnauzer for animal welfare causes.

Maddie, an inspiration for a fund

Maddie, who inspired a fund

There are some similarities between Maddie and Trouble. Both were much loved by wealthy owners who wanted to show their gratitude for the joy they received from their pups by helping other dogs.

Dave and Cheryl Duffield fell head-over-heels for Maddie when she was only ten days old. “We held her in our arms, and loved her immediately,” says Dave. “Maddie melted our hearts from the first second we saw her,” adds Cheryl, “with her sweet ways, her stubbornness, her independence, her intelligence, her spirit, and her devotion.”
Dave, Cheryl and Maddie shared ten memorable and happy years together. Dave remembers one particularly good day during the formation of his company, PeopleSoft.

But, as far as public perception is concerned, the differences are more important.  Dave and Cheryl Duffield, Maddie’s owners, are not famous outside of philanthropic circles, where they’re known for  having given more money to animal welfare causes — especially creating shelter medicine programs in veterinary schools, supporting no-kill shelters, and promoting spay and neuter programs — than any other individuals, nearly $400 million to date. And, unlike Trouble, Maddie led a low key, normal doggie life.

And Maddie died, while her owners are still alive and able to express their love for her, in tributes as well as in contributions. (I defy any dog lover  — well, okay, any dog lover of the female persuasion — to look at the website devoted to her without crying.) As a result, the Duffields are able to stand up for those who would deny others, including Leona Helmsely, the same opportunity.

A press release from the Maddie’s Fund site says in reference to the case being brought against Helmsely’s trustees:

“Literally hundreds of millions of dollars that have been willed by people nationally, who cared about dogs, have not gone to provide for dogs as was intended,” said Rich Avanzino, president of Maddie’s Fund. “The ignoring of donor intent in this country has become an unspoken national shame.

With $5 billion at stake this is a game changer. We want to work with the Helmsley trustees to arrive at a figure that is consistent with Mrs. Helmsley’s intentions and would change injustices in dog care and welfare overnight.

For instance, even a small fraction of this money makes it possible to virtually empty all animal shelters in America of dogs without homes.”

So if you’re troubled by Trouble as the face of dog rescue, think of Maddie. And speak out against the New York Surrogate Court’s decision to disregard a will designed to help dogs in need.

This entry was posted in Animal Welfare and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


  1. Clare
    Posted August 16, 2009 at 7:09 pm | Permalink

    Coincidentally I just read this while seeing Michael Vick interviewed on “60 Minutes”. Maddie indeed choked me up, not the least because she reminded me of my own intrepid terriorist. I plan to support Maddie’s Fund, especially as I see the horror that is Vick. Thank you so much for writing about this.

    • admin
      Posted August 17, 2009 at 8:10 am | Permalink

      As it happens, I was also thinking about Vick while I was writing this. Both he and Helmsley are high profile, controversial figures — with the key difference that Helmsley redeemed herself in the minds of many (including me) with her love for animals while Vick is fake redeeming himself with his love of the money the NFL is going to give him.

4 Trackbacks

  1. […] that pets are overindulged — you know, like the executors of Leona Helmsley’s estate who decided that they knew better where her money should go after she died than she did. Human health insurance is a hot button topic these days too, of course, […]

  2. By Pet peeve: Second-guessing dog gifts on October 6, 2010 at 11:50 am

    […] you’re flush enough to do both, like Leona Helmsley was, more power to you. Then again, it’s really none of my business–which is the best […]

  3. […] a post written when the case first went to court, I noted that Leona Helmsley was not the ideal spokeswoman […]

  4. By The Shelter Pet Project, Pt. 1: Changing Perceptions on December 27, 2011 at 6:16 am

    […] already written about Maddie’s Fund in the context of another of the organization’s collaborative projects, to get Leona […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>